How to identify bird egg thieves

You can learn a lot from broken bird eggs, including whether they hatched naturally or were predated.

Red fox (Vulpes vulpes) with a chicken egg in its mouth, looking directly at the camera

Birds’ eggs are a nutritious source of food, so it’s hardly surprising that lots of animals eat them.

Advertisement

In summer, egg remains are common, so if you find one, first check if it hatched normally. If it didn’t, it is often possible to identify the thief from the signs left behind. Keep your eyes open and check the evidence carefully – it’s not just the usual suspects that steal birds’ eggs …

Broken pheasant eggs in the nest after being predated by corvids
Broken pheasant eggs in the nest after being predated by corvids. © Mark Hamblin/Getty

HOW TO TELL IF AN EGG HATCHED NATURALLY OR WAS PREDATED

Naturally hatched eggs

  • Most eggshells you find will have been thrown from nests after the chicks hatched or are the remains of ground-nesting birds’ eggs that hatched normally.
  • When hatching, chicks use their egg-tooth (a horny spike on the upper mandible) to make a circular cut across the blunt end of the egg; the edge is jagged where the chick has chipped its way out.
  • As the empty shell dries out, the inner membrane contracts and ‘rolls’ the chipped edge inwards.
  • Unlike predated eggs, hatched eggs never have yolk or egg-white left inside the shell.
  • The two halves of the shell are often found close together. To remove them from the nest, the parent may carry one half of the egg inside the other.
A hatched bird egg © Charlotte Bleijenberg / Getty
A naturally hatched bird egg. © Charlotte Bleijenberg/Getty

MEET THE PREDATORS

Mustelids

  • Pine martens and polecats generally carry eggs off to eat elsewhere. They characteristically bite across the egg, leaving an oblong or rectangular hole through which they lick up the contents. Small canine tooth punctures may be left in the eggshell.
  • Stoats and weasels, being smaller, eat larger eggs in the nest. They bite a hole in one or both ends of the egg.
Pine marten licking egg yolk from a rock in the forest after stealing and smashing bird egg
Pine marten licking egg yolk from a rock in the forest after stealing and smashing bird egg. © Zoran Kolundzija/Getty

Foxes

  • Foxes generally carry eggs away from nests. They may then eat them or they will cache (bury) them for consumption later.
  • The whole egg is taken in the mouth, crushed and the contents eaten. Eggshells are left some distance from the nest.
  • A fox will often catch mallards, pheasants and partridges on their nests. If this has happened, the nest will be damaged, with scattered feathers if the carcass has been carried away or the remains of the carcass if it has been eaten nearby.
Red Fox (Vulpes vulpes) stealing an egg
A red fox stealing a bird egg. © Horst Jegen/Getty

Rats

  • Rats prefer the large, cryptic eggs of colonial nesting birds and consume the eggs in the nest.
  • They make a hole in the side or end of the egg with characteristic chip marks, then lick out the contents.
  • Squirrel signs are very similar.
  • A common myth is that rats co-operate to steal hens’ eggs – one lies on its back, holding the egg to its chest, while another rat pulls out the content with its tail. This is not true.
A brown rat sniffs leftovers on a plate in the kitchen
Brown rats will eat pretty much anything, and they’ll certainly take eggs if they can get them. © tenra/Getty

Cuckoos

  • Cuckoos parasitise the nests of many birds, typically dunnocks, pipits, robins, wagtails and warblers.
  • A female cuckoo lays one egg in each nest and removes one of the host’s eggs.
  • The cuckoo hatches first and then ejects the eggs or nestlings of the host. It squirms beneath them, rears backwards against the sides of the nest with its back arched and wings raised, and then rolls the egg or nestling over the edge of the nest cup.
  • The eggs or nestlings can be found below the nest; the eggs will normally have a well-developed embryo inside.
Cuckoo (Cuculus canorus) chick being fed by its Reed Warbler host bird (Acrocephalus scirpaceus), brood parasite
A cuckoo chick being fed by its host bird, a reed warbler that’s already smaller than the cuckoo. © Thomas Hinsche/Getty

Crows

  • Crows and other corvids (magpies, jackdaws, rooks, ravens and jays) are probably the most common predators of bird nests. They actively search hedgerows for nests and scan the ground from trees for nesting birds.
  • They make a small puncture in the side or end of the egg, then insert their upper bill into the hole to lift the egg and drain the contents.
  • They may eat the egg on the nest but often carry it off – remains of several eggs can be found at favoured eating points. Gulls make similar holes but generally eat the egg on the nest.
Advertisement
Magpie with a stolen egg in its beak
Magpie stealing an egg to eat away from the nest. © StockPhotoAstur/Getty

Hedgehogs

  •  Hedgehogs drive sitting birds off their nests and eat the eggs in situ.
  •  They bite a large hole in the side of the shell and lick up the contents.
  •  All that remains are shallow cups of eggs, shattered fragments of eggshell and the remains of the contents spattered around the nest.
Close-up of a Hedgehog (Erinaceus europaeus) on green grass in Scottish countryside
We might think hedgehogs look cute, but they’re voracious predators that love birds eggs. © Nature Picture Library / Getty