Why can only big cats roar?

BBC Wildlife writer Stephen Mills answers your wild question.


There are four big cats that can roar: lion, tiger, leopard and jaguar – all of which belong to the genus Panthera.


In these species, the epihyal bone, part of the voice box, is replaced by a ligament. This can be stretched, creating a larger sound-producing passage and thus a wider range of pitch. The more the ligament extends, the lower the sound generated when air passes across the vocal cords. In addition, the cords are large, unbroken and fleshy, which produces deeper sounds.

Roaring tiger (Panthera tigris)
Roaring tiger. © SKapl/Getty

In contrast, in the ‘small’ cats, the bones of the voice box form a fixed structure, with divided vocal cords that vibrate with both in and out breaths. While this design enables these cats to purr continuously (unlike their big cousins), it limits the range of other sounds and prevents them from being able to roar. Even large species, such as pumas and cheetahs, whose voice boxes are proportionately big, possess small-cat anatomy.

Interestingly, the snow leopard – also a member of Panthera – cannot roar. Its vocal cords lack an all-important layer of fatty, elasticated tissue, which, in other big cats, gives the vocalisations an uneven rumble that emerges as a roar. Some scientists therefore argue that the snow leopard deserves its own genus: Uncia.

Everyone loves big cats, and we’ve got loads of features to keep you interested. Take a look at these ones for a start!

Why do big cats usually stalk and pounce?

Which big cat has the strongest bite?

Could there really be big cats in the British countryside?

Photo © Freder/Getty

Close up of a tiger's eyes (Panthera tigris)

Do you have a wildlife question you’d like answered? Email your question to wildquestions@immediate.co.uk or post it to Q&A, BBC Wildlife Magazine, Immediate Media Company, 2nd Floor, Tower House, Fairfax Street, Bristol, BS1 3BN